MLB 06 The Show VS High Heat 2002 PC

I actually have a lot of work to do this afternoon. This morning I took Ashley to her Kintergarten placement testing. Did anyone else have to do this when they were a kid? We just sorta got thrown into school. The tests were easy, even for a 5 year old, so I think it’s just a test to see if cognitively everything is ok. Which block is blue, repeat these sentences, what steps do you take to brush your teeth? That sorta thing. I was in the room with her during these tests, sitting quietly but wanting to shout out an answer if she paused after a question. It’s a trick Ashley, they’re all blue blocks! Anyway, she had a blast. She ‘passed’ the test and will start school in August.

But that took most of the morning. Well, that and a father/daughter breakfast at the local family restaurant. I love this little town. Pretty much every store/shop and eatery takes cash or check. No debit cards. Even the Subway takes checks and doesn’t take a Visa. I’ll get used to it. I’m even learning to accept the damn rooster. After we ate breakfast I saw that the guy we bought our PT Cruiser from was sitting at the counter drinking coffee. He said hi and asked about the Cruiser, then asked the waitress, whom he addressed by her first name, for more coffee.

Daddy’s in Mayberry. I have to get Todd out here. Some fresh air will do him some good.

Anyway, that was my morning and like I said I do have a lot of work to do. GameSpy sent me a beta of Heroes of Might and Magic V which I really want to see, being a fan of the series since the original back in the days of DOS. I also need to edit this TP Golf interview (which is pretty good) and start on a dreadfully late review of BFME2.

But I keep thinking about MLB 06: The Show.

A week or so ago my buddy Bill Harris blogged that The Show was a significantly better game than High Heat Baseball, a game that he knows damn well I hold near and dear to my heart. (I come to find out later that he was specifically talking about the PSP version). I recently had a chance to play the old HH on the PC again because my dad installed it on an old Win98SE machine just so he could play it. (High Heat hates XP.) A few mods were installed, a tune file tweaked, and the high-res stadiums added. High Heat 2002 PC still, to this day, plays a very good game of baseball. It’s fast, simple, and addcitive with an interface to die for.

But like so many things in life, some things are better the way we remember them rather than how they actually were in reality. The ball physics in HH are very simple — you never see a high chopper or a very slow roller and pitched balls move at a snail’s pace compared to today’s games. One of my problems with the HH PBI was that it was tough for the CPU to strike me out, even with everything tweaked. Still, for a 5 year old game High Heat 2002 PC holds up remarkably well.

But The Show, on the field, just might be better. It still cannot compare to High Heat’s game interface, which no console game can do. It’s taken me about 20 games to warm up to it but right now I’m red hot lovin’ this game. I’m playing a Reds franchise, playing one game of each series and simming the rest (my usual MO in baseball games) and it’s uncanny how authentic the game feels at times. With Dunn I either walk, whiff, or hit a 500 foot homer. I miss a lot of pitches with Dunn that I can drill with Felipe Lopez. My starters are decent enough but I have lost about 10 leads due to the tradegy that is the Reds bullpen. When it’s time to bring in a relief pitcher, I feel like I’m walking to the gallows. Rarely do I see something that makes me think to myself, ‘Well that was just stupid.’

I strikeout, I walk, I hit doubles now thanks to lowering arm accuracy and stregnth a bit, and am genrerally having the most fun playing arcade baseball since, well, High Heat 2002 PC. And it feels really good.

8 Responses to “MLB 06 The Show VS High Heat 2002 PC”

  1. Craig Tompkins Says:

    Bill are you playing the PSP version too or the PS2 versoin?

  2. bill Says:

    PS2, I should have been clear on that, sorry.

  3. Jeff Says:

    I take it it’s not available on PC, huh? We PC users are really getting screwed.

  4. bill Says:

    Yep. And this would make for a fantastic PC game, too.

  5. pb4201 Says:

    can you post your sliders?

  6. srudoff Says:

    I’m going to catch grief for this, but I think MVP 2006 (the fully modded update from mvpmods.com) on the pc is a better overall game than any of the high heat iterations. High heat was great, but I think nostalgia is playing too big of a factor with it now - people remember only the great things and none of the other stuff. MVP with all the datafiles to make pitching harder, plus all the stadiums, rosters, etc is a great game. Right now, someone is very close to making something similar to danger z’s editor - a fully functional editor for dynasties. they also might be close to hexing the game to make the default season 2006 instead of 2005.

  7. bill Says:

    Why would you catch grief for that?

    I like MVP, too. I think it was a year away from being really special. I haven’t tried all of the mods for it but the ease of the pitch meter really turned me off, as did the interface. After looking over the stuff that’s in the mega mod pack I’m not surprised that it’s a much better game now. I just haven’t had a chance to play it.

  8. inthenet Says:

    I truly miss PC Baseball, and have come to the decision that maybe the MVP2006 mod may be my only hope.

    Like Bill and others that read this blog, I am a die-hard High Heater, and the pitching interface for MVP was just too simple. I was also a HUGE fan of HighHeat’s manage only mode and despised MVP’s Manage mode.

    Anyway, Bill, please let us know your thoughts on HOMMV as I too am a big fan… In fact, my only claim to literary fame would be a couple of small contibutions to one of the HOMM II FAQs that’s still floating around the net.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.