First off, that was a hell of a football game. To be there, with great seats, is another father/son memory I’ll never forget. Me, my dad and my uncle had an emotionally draining, voice-ripping good time. My throat is a mess this morning. I feel like I’m hungover even though I didn’t drink a drop. 5 of 6 against Michigan is a feeling only a Michigan fan can understand. It’s the Cooper era in reverse.
OK the rematch. The talking heads, most of them, are clamoring for it. I have said from day one that a rematch would be unfair to the winner — and I still feel that way. OSU exorcised the Michigan spectre in 2006. The game’s over. OSU won. Michigan should get the grand daddy of all consolation prizes and play in the Rose Bowl. No shame in that.
My argument is that no team should lose its conference and its final game and still play for a title. It’s wrong. This has nothing to do with the rivalry, although I think a game played outside of Ann Arbor or Columbus dilutes the game a hell of a lot. It wouldn’t be the same.
I considered last night’s game a playoff game with the winner getting a title shot. Is Michigan clearly the #2 team in the country? I don’t know. We’re still playing the speculation game, which continues to be the elephant in the room inside this sport. I know that OSU put up 500 yards on them and neatly gift-wrapped 10 points to them and gave away another scoring chance with their 2nd botched shotgun snap. Yes, it was a 3 point game and one for the ages, but I think OSU was clearly the better of the two teams. The Buckeyes, just like 2005, did everything they could to keep Michigan in it.
Here’s another problem: Notre Dame. Michigan fans are saying, rightly IMO, that no way should ND get a shot after Michigan beat them earlier in the year. Well, this is the same logic I’m using. If OSU would play Michigan again, the whole time I would be thinking, “Damn, we just beat these guys.” What if Michigan wins the rematch 27-26 on a last second field goal? What the hell have we decided?
Finally, Mike Hart. I’m willing to cut Hart some slack after losing a game like that with Michigan still with a heavy heart after the loss of Bo. I get that. If you’re that torn up, don’t sit down in front of a mic and do a post game presser. Hart ‘guarantees’ that in a rematch Michigan would win and win big, that OSU’s defense was nothing special and flatly ‘not that good.’ It’s a shame that such a great game has to end on a sour note like that. The guy played a whale of a game, and perhaps he’s right that the OSU defense isn’t as vaunted as some thought, (one can say the same for the Wolves unit) but they were clearly good enough to beat Michigan.